Forced to be second
Punishment

Carnations are now with his best friend, in one of the closest caffe, because their lecture hours are also finished, so they can relax for a moment. They are now talking about the slander that is circulating about Anyelir, they are very curious about who has spread the slander, and they go directly to Gita, Anyelir's half-brother. Because, they are very understanding as to what Gita attitude to Carnations, full of envy and envy, to the extent that Carnation's lover alone is captured by Gita.

“Do not recriminate first, we do not have evidence,” said Anyelir advised his friends who were burning with anger.

“We do not accuse Nye, I have tried to ask one of my friends who is one class with Gita, and said he was really Gita who had spread this fake news,” said Ana with a look of annoyance, she did not accept her closest friend in vile slander.

“Iya Nye, and loe denger himself right? Some say that Gita instead said it is impossible bokap loe who bought a car,” Dinda began chiming in.

“Nye, you can't stay in them, Gita has gone too far to know, you've sacrificed for the family, and what Gita has now, it's all because of your sacrifice, you know, but what he did,” Nabila also ignited emois. Seeing his friends who seemed to not accept, crossed the idea of ignorant Carnations. He pulled out his phone, and asked his friends to shut up, Anyelir started looking for someone's phone number and called him.

But, there are things that make Nabila, Dinda and Ana confused, which is because Carnations pretend to be crying, two as much as they want to try to contact the number of someone who has not known friends.

“Halo father ...” Carnation started his drama, apparently he contacted Agam.

“Anyelir? Why you nak?” there was a voice of Agam who seemed to worry about the condition of his daughter.

“Dad, please Anye ..” isak Anyelir more deep into his role.

“Please? What happened to you son?” the voice of Agam was getting more anxious.

“Kak Gita .. he slandered me,” his stuffing, made Agam to link his eyebrows, if there is a name Gita called by Anyelir, must be bad.

“What is your sister doing?” this time Agam's tone sounded serious, initially Anyelir pretended as if he refused to tell Agam what really happened, citing fear that Gita and her father had a fight. But, Agam assures that everything will be fine. Carnations began to tell about the car he was driving, until finally he told how Gita spread the hoax news until one campus beratai Anyelir women who are not good.

Hearing the words of his youngest daughter, of course Agam was very angry and disappointed with Gita who defamed Anyelir, but clearly Gita knew who the car was from. Even if Gita does not like Carnations, what should she lead the opinions of students and students there to think badly about Carnations?

“Dad, I can't defend myself now, because I know right? the condition of Devan's brother,” when talking to his father, then Anyelir will replace the call to Devan with a sak, so that his father does not suspect that his relationship with Devan is very stiff and cold.

“Alright, you calm down, I will take care of everything,” said Agam assured Anyelir.

“Well well, I'm just afraid that Devan knows and will be angry with Kak Gita, and I'm afraid it will have a bad impact on the company father,” said Anyelir in a sad tone.

“Iya son, you take it easy, I will give your brother a lesson,” said Agam assured Anyelir, after finishing complaining to his father, Anyelir smiled at all his friends, because the plan had succeeded.

**

“Gita,” Agam's cold voice greeted Gita's hearing, making Gita frown, seeing her father's expression that seemed to be holding back anger.

“Dad?” Gita approached her father who was sitting in the living room.

“What did Dad call me?” Gita asked, as if nothing had happened.

Plaaq!!!  One hard samparan landed onto Gita's smooth cheek, making the girl feel hot on her cheek.

“Why Daddy slapped me!” gita is full of emotions.

“You should get more of this!!” exclaiming Agam is not inferior to his daughter, if all this time maybe he will only be silent when Gita snapped it, but this time not. He will teach his daughter to be more polite to others.

“A-I'm wrong what's Yah?” gita's tone began to stare, she was afraid to see her father who was in the middle of emotions.

“You asked what is your fault?! think about what you did to Carnation!” exclaiming Agam, hearing the name Carnation called, made Gita more upset, he did not like if the people in his house just continue to talk about the name of Carnation.

“Anyelir and Carnation continue, can you not focus on me? I'm Dad's daughter!” exclaiming Gita, he looked at Agam with disappointment, whereas all this time Agam always acted fairly to his two daughters, even he felt, his affection had only been directed to Gita, but he had always been, because guilt has betrayed Mother Gita.

“Father has been fair to you, and you must remember, Carnation is your sister Gita! If it wasn't for him, maybe you couldn't enjoy this luxury, you couldn't have continued your studies, can't you just say thank you to Carnation for sacrificing for this family? or at least if you don't like Carnations, then don't push her away!” now that Gita understands where her father is talking, she believes that Anyelir complained to his father about the news about Carnations on campus.

“Kamari kamari kan bag you,” Agam said, but there was a rejection from Gita, making Agam finally act rude, he grabbed the bag belonging to Gita with rough. He took Gita's wallet, and took the atm, the credit card, and the car keys.

“Daddy will confiscate all this, and I will return it later when you have cleared the name Anyelir,” said Agam firmly.

“Dad, I can't, and I don't know how,” refused Gita, she herself confused what to do, she said, because if he admits everything that he talks about Carnations is a lie, then he will be the months on campus later.

“Daddy does not care, if you really can't, yes already then all this will be in the hands of Dad forever,” Agam immediately left Gita who is still whining and begging for the car keys, so that all this will be in the hands of Dad, atm and his credit card were returned, but Aga seemed to care about his hearing, he continued to step towards the room. And while on the stairs, he passed by Rosse, who was staring at Gita with pity.

“Do not interfere, and do not try to help him, or you will also feel the consequences,” Agam commemorates Rosse, because usually Rosse who will laboriously help Gita, but this time there was no rejection of Rosse, he nodded in understanding, so Agam felt relieved.

Actually, Agam also felt sorry for Gita, but he could not continue to let Gita hurt Carnations, however the Carnations were not guilty, because Agam and Rosse were guilty. Agam also wants Gita to change into more mature, Agam wants Gita to be able to appreciate the sacrifice of Carnations who have been willing to replace Gita married to Dvan. And his firmness all this time was also for the good of his daughters, because Agam did not know until when he was in this world, he did not want to regret because he had failed in educating his children.